4338.217 · August 5, 2018 AD
Two Investigations, One Table
Stout pins Karl's obsession wall to a whiteboard in an empty meeting room on a Sunday morning and waits for Sienna Blackwood to see what he's seeing. What follows is two investigators laying their cases side by side for the first time — and watching the connections multiply faster than they can write them down. By the time the phone rings, the investigation they walked in with isn't the investigation they're walking out of.
"Parallel cases on converging evidence is a waste of time. Whatever this is, it's one thing — and it's bigger than either of us mapped alone." — Detective Inspector Sienna Blackwood
The station was quiet on a Sunday.
Stout arrived at eight. He'd slept — not well, not long, but enough that his hands were steady and his eyes could focus on the pages he needed to read. The corridors were half-lit, the overhead fluorescents cycling on as he passed beneath them and clicking off again behind him, the building conserving energy for a day it didn't expect to be busy.
He'd booked Meeting Room 2 — the smaller one at the end of the CID corridor, away from the main operations floor. A rectangular table, six chairs, a whiteboard on one wall, a window that looked onto the car park. The kind of room where work happened without ceremony.
He set up alone. Laid his materials across the table in the order he'd present them — Sarah's interview first, then the house search, then the enlarged photographs of Karl's living room wall. The USB drive containing the audio and video. His handwritten notes. The post-interview assessment he'd typed at his desk on Friday afternoon while the Berriedale house was still standing. The preliminary evidence log from yesterday's search. Donovan's scene photographs printed on A4.
He pinned the enlarged photographs to the whiteboard. Karl's web filled most of the board — the red string, the pinned documents, the handwritten notes dense in the margins. Names the reader of this wall couldn't avoid: Jamie Greyson. Kain Jeffries. Luke Smith. Jeffries Manor. And in the lower corner, connected by a single thread, Killerton Enterprises.
Stout stepped back. Looked at it. The obsession of a man who'd stopped sleeping, laid out on a whiteboard in an empty meeting room on a Sunday morning by the detective assigned to find him.
He needed coffee.
The kitchen was at the other end of the CID corridor — a narrow room with a sink, a kettle, a refrigerator that nobody cleaned, and a coffee machine that worked on alternate days depending on factors nobody had successfully identified. Stout walked the corridor in the Sunday stillness, his shoes loud on the linoleum, the closed office doors on either side holding whatever their occupants had left behind on Friday afternoon.
He smelled the coffee before he reached the kitchen. Someone had already made a pot.
Woolley was standing at the bench with a mug in one hand and a manila folder in the other, reading something with the unhurried attention of a man who'd come in early specifically to read without interruption. His jacket was off — draped over the back of a chair — and his sleeves were rolled to the forearm. He looked up when Stout appeared in the doorway.
"Stout."
"Sir."
The word landed between them with all its ordinary weight and all its recent history. Thirty-six hours since Woolley's voice had come through Stout's phone at Jeffries Manor — flat, compressed, delivering a directive that had shut down an operation eleven minutes before it would have opened a hearthstone that had been sealed for two centuries. Thirty-six hours since Stout had stood in the foyer with an unsigned authorisation and a pen that never reached the paper.
"Didn't expect anyone else in today," Woolley said. He closed the folder and set it on the bench — face down, the gesture automatic, the habit of a man who'd spent twenty years in a profession where open documents were read by whoever walked past.
"Briefing to prepare for." Stout moved to the coffee machine. The pot was half full. He took a clean mug from the shelf — one of the station's standard-issue white ceramics, chipped at the rim, stained from a decade of use — and poured.
"On a Sunday."
"Couldn't wait."
Woolley leaned against the bench. He held his mug with both hands, the way people held mugs when they weren't planning to leave a conversation quickly. His face was the same face Stout had known for years — broad, weathered, the eyes carrying the particular steadiness of a man who'd risen through the ranks by knowing when to press and when to absorb. A face that gave you exactly what it chose to give you and nothing more.
"The Berriedale fire," Woolley said. "I saw the reports. Arson confirmed?"
"Gallagher's preliminary came through yesterday afternoon. Multiple ignition points. Accelerant. Deliberate."
"And it was Blackwood's scene."
"Her crime scene, yes. The shooting on the second — Kate Gibbons. The property was cordoned under her investigation when someone set fire to it."
Woolley's eyes didn't move from Stout's face. He was listening the way Inspectors listened — not just to the words but to the shape of them, to what was being included and what was being steered around.
"You were there," Woolley said. Not a question.
"I was notified because of the overlap with my investigation. Karl had the property flagged — Luke Smith's residence. Connected to the missing persons chain."
"And now it's gone."
"The physical evidence from the scene is gone. Blackwood's team had collected blood samples before the fire — those survived. Everything else is ash."
Woolley drank from his mug. Set it down. Picked up his folder, then set that down too — the small restless movements of a man processing something he hadn't come here to process.
"How's the Jenkins investigation tracking, Stout?"
The question arrived with the weight of everything that sat behind it. Karl's disappearance. The manor withdrawal. Sarah's interview. The house search. The staged bedroom. The web of red string and names and connections pinned to a whiteboard sixty metres down the corridor.
Stout drank his coffee. It was better than yesterday's — stronger, less bitter, the machine apparently having one of its cooperative days.
"It's expanding," he said.
"Expanding how?"
"The scope is wider than a single missing person. Karl's investigation was wider than what he'd filed officially. We're discovering that as we go."
Woolley's jaw shifted. A fractional movement — the muscle tightening and releasing along the hinge. Stout had seen that movement before. In briefings, when information arrived that Woolley hadn't anticipated. In the corridor outside the Superintendent's office, when decisions came down that he hadn't been consulted on. The jaw was Woolley's tell — the one piece of his composure that operated independently of his control.
"You said a briefing. Who with?"
"DI Blackwood. Her investigation and mine are intersecting at multiple points. We're mapping the overlaps."
"Blackwood." Woolley repeated the name the way he'd repeat any name — neutrally, placing it, filing it. "That's her initiative or yours?"
"Mutual. The fire forced the question. We're dealing with the same people, the same property, the same network of connections. Running parallel investigations on converging cases wastes resources and creates gaps."
"And you're doing this through —"
"Through each other. Direct coordination. Her case files and mine."
Woolley picked up his mug again. Held it without drinking. The kitchen was silent except for the refrigerator's hum and the distant sound of a door closing somewhere in the building — the weekend duty officer making rounds, or a cleaner starting early, or nothing at all.
"Stout." Woolley's voice had shifted. Not dramatically — a half-tone lower, the register he used when he was about to say something that wasn't entirely professional and wasn't entirely personal but occupied the territory between the two. "I know the last few days have been —" He stopped. Started again. "The manor. I know how that landed."
Stout said nothing. He held his coffee and waited.
"The directive didn't originate with me. I want you to know that. It came through channels that I —" Another stop. Woolley looked at his mug as though the correct word might be floating in it. "I communicated it because that's my job. But I didn't generate it."
Stout absorbed this the way he absorbed everything Woolley said — carefully, completely, without committing to what it meant. The statement could be true. It could be the practiced deflection of a man who'd been complicit in shutting down an investigation and was now managing the fallout. It could be both — a man who'd genuinely opposed the directive but lacked the authority or the will to override it. The statement told Stout nothing he could act on and everything he needed to hold at a distance.
"Understood, sir."
"I'm not asking you to forgive it. I'm asking you to understand that the landscape around this case is —" Woolley set his mug down with a deliberateness that suggested the next word mattered more than the mug. "Complex."
"Complex."
"There are factors in play that extend beyond CID. Beyond this station. Factors that I'm not at liberty to discuss in a kitchen on a Sunday morning and that you may not be fully aware of."
The sentence hung in the air between them. Stout turned it over. Factors that extend beyond CID. The phrase could mean political pressure — the Jeffries family's influence, their connections, the calls that Tom Jeffries had made and that had produced results within an hour. Or it could mean something else. Something institutional. Something that lived in the space between what an Inspector was told and what an Inspector was permitted to share.
"Are you telling me to be careful?" Stout asked.
Woolley met his eyes. Held them. The kitchen light caught his face from the side — the lines deeper than Stout remembered, the skin beneath his eyes carrying the particular weight of insufficient sleep accumulated over weeks rather than days.
"I'm telling you that the directive didn't originate with me." Woolley paused. His thumb moved along the edge of his folder — back and forth, back and forth, the small unconscious rhythm of a man choosing each word before releasing it. "And I'm telling you to be careful which questions you ask. And who you ask them to."
The refrigerator hummed. A pipe somewhere in the wall made a sound like someone tapping a fingernail against metal.
"Thank you, sir," Stout said. And meant it — though what he meant by it, he wasn't entirely sure. Thank you for the honesty, if that's what it was. Thank you for the warning, if that's what it was. Thank you for standing in a kitchen and saying something that, in another context, from another man, might sound like an admission that the institution they both served had been compromised at a level neither of them could see.
Woolley picked up his folder. His jacket. His mug.
"Whatever you and Blackwood are building," he said from the doorway, "build it properly. Because if it's as wide as you say it is, there'll be people who'd prefer it stayed narrow." He paused. Something moved behind his eyes — not quite hesitation, not quite decision. "And Stout. Be careful. You don't want to end up like Jenkins."
The words landed in the kitchen and stayed there.
Woolley held Stout's gaze for a beat longer than the sentence required. Then he turned and walked down the corridor. His footsteps receded — measured, even, the pace of a man returning to his office and his paperwork and his Sunday. The fluorescent lights clicked on ahead of him and off behind him and the corridor was empty again.
Stout stood in the kitchen with the coffee cooling in his hand and the residue of a sentence that could have meant three different things and that Woolley had delivered without clarifying which one he intended. You don't want to end up like Jenkins. A warning about obsession. A warning about something else. Or something worse than a warning — the words of a man who knew more about what had happened to Karl than a directive without explanation should have given him.
He topped up his mug from the pot. Walked back to Meeting Room 2 where Karl's obsession wall waited on the whiteboard and the files waited on the table and the morning waited for Sienna to arrive.
The coffee was strong. The corridor was empty. And Woolley's last sentence walked beside him all the way back to the door.
Sienna arrived at eight-thirty.
Stout heard her before he saw her — footsteps in the CID corridor, unhurried, the even rhythm of someone who walked the same way regardless of whether the building was full or empty. She appeared in the doorway of Meeting Room 2 carrying a document box under one arm and a takeaway coffee in the other hand.
She set the box on the table and the coffee beside it and looked at the whiteboard.
The photographs of Karl's living room wall filled most of it — the web of red string and pinned documents and handwritten connections, enlarged and arranged in the same configuration they'd occupied on Karl's walls. Sienna stepped closer. Her eyes moved across the web with the same methodical sweep Stout had watched her apply to the Berriedale ruins — left to right, top to bottom, reading the whole before examining the parts.
She didn't speak for nearly a minute. Stout let the silence hold. This was the first time Sienna was seeing what Karl had built in the weeks before he disappeared, and the weight of it needed to land without interruption.
"This was in his living room," she said finally. Not a question.
"Covered two walls and was spreading onto a third. The dining table, the coffee table, sections of the floor. His sofa was facing the wall, not the television."
Sienna's finger found Jamie Greyson's photograph at the top left. Red string ran from Jamie to Luke Smith — partners, cohabitants, the Berriedale property anchoring them both. From Jamie, a thread to Kain Jeffries. From Kain back to Luke — a triangle of connections, each person linked to the other two. From Jamie, another thread across to Louise Jeffries — siblings, the family connection that tied the Greyson disappearance to the manor. From Louise back to Luke — visits, conversations, a link Karl had documented. From Louise to Kain — both at the manor, Kain living there with his fiancée Brianne Sitch. Brianne's photograph sat close to Kain's, connected by a short red thread and a note in Karl's handwriting that Stout couldn't fully read from where he stood but that he knew from the evidence log: she'd disappeared from the manor less than an hour before Karl himself.
Another cluster sat to the right — Nial Triffett, Adrian Pafistis, Karen and Chris Owen. Each of them connected to Luke Smith by their own red threads, four more missing persons radiating outward from the same centre point. Luke's photograph had become a hub — strings fanning out from it in every direction, every missing person connected back to him through one path or another.
Sienna's finger followed each connection without touching the board, hovering a centimetre from the surface, mapping the architecture of Karl's obsession in the air.
"How long was he building this?"
"Some of the pinned documents are background research — printed profiles, property records, things Karl could have pulled at any point. But the connections, the red string, the handwritten notes linking everything together — the earliest dates I can see are the twenty-eighth of July. Five days. He built all of this in five days."
"Off the books."
"None of this was in his official case files. What he filed at the station was clean, methodical, precisely what you'd expect from Karl. This —" Stout gestured at the whiteboard. "This was something else."
Sienna's finger had reached the lower right corner. A cluster of documents sat apart from the rest of the web — separated by a gap that felt deliberate, as though Karl had placed them at a distance from the main investigation because he didn't yet know how they connected. At the centre of the cluster, a photograph. Not a face — an object. A rectangular card, photographed against what looked like a kitchen bench. Beside the photograph, in Karl's handwriting: Unidentified male — Berriedale property. Access card found on body.
Red string ran from the photograph to a single destination: Killerton Enterprises. Corporate filings. Registration documents. A Wikipedia page annotated in Karl's hand. The connection wasn't through Luke Smith or any of the missing persons threads that dominated the main web. It ran from an unnamed body to an access card to an American construction company, and it sat on Karl's wall like a door he'd found but hadn't yet opened.
Sienna stopped there.
"Tell me about this."
"Two things. The first — Karl found a body at the Berriedale property. Before your team, before Kate Gibbons, before any of it. He was there, he found an unidentified male, and he took something from the body. An access card." Stout paused. Let that land. A detective removing evidence from a scene. "The second — the access card was issued by Killerton Enterprises. American construction company, headquartered in San Francisco. Karl didn't know who the dead man was. He labelled him on the wall as 'unidentified male' and connected him directly to Killerton through the card. Then he started digging — corporate records, property filings. His notes in the margin read: Construction company? San Francisco. What's the connection to Jeffries? And further down, added later: Property records. Who built the manor? Check foundations. Check modifications."
Sienna was very still. Her finger remained near the board, suspended in the air beside the photograph of the access card.
"Karl found a body at the Berriedale property," she said. "And didn't report it."
"No."
"And removed evidence from the scene."
"Yes."
The room held the weight of what that meant. A senior detective finding a body and concealing it. A senior detective taking physical evidence and building a private investigation around it. Whatever Karl had been doing in those final days, it had crossed lines that couldn't be uncrossed — lines that separated investigation from obstruction, detective from suspect.
"The unidentified male on Karl's wall," Sienna said slowly. "And the unidentified male my team found in the lower level of the same property on the evening of the second."
"Could be the same person."
"If it is, then Karl knew about the body before we did. He knew and he didn't call it in. He took evidence and he walked away." Sienna's voice carried no judgment — not yet. She was building a sequence. Laying facts end to end. "And then Kate Gibbons entered the same house days later, found the same body, called triple zero, and died holding a knife she'd picked up because she was terrified of what she'd walked into."
The connection settled between them like something heavy placed on glass.
"If Karl had reported that body when he found it," Sienna said, "Kate Gibbons would still be alive."
Stout said nothing. There was nothing to say. The arithmetic was simple and it was devastating and it sat on the table beside the case files and the coffee cups and the photographs like a fact that would reshape everything they were building.
Sienna studied the Killerton cluster for several more seconds.
"There's something else in the cluster," Stout said. "Lower down. Easy to miss."
Sienna looked where he indicated. Below the Killerton documents, partially obscured by a printed financial record that had been pinned over it, two lines drawn in red pen — not string this time, but ink, drawn directly onto the wall. One line ran from a small square Karl had labelled with his own name. The other ran from Jamie Greyson's photograph in the main web. Both lines converged on the Killerton Enterprises documents, meeting at a point Karl had circled and marked with a large question mark. Beside the question mark, in handwriting that was smaller and more hurried than his usual precise lettering, three letters and a date.
QLD 2003.
Sienna stared at it.
"Karl connected himself to this," she said.
"To Killerton. And to Jamie Greyson. Fifteen years ago. Queensland, 2003 — the year Karl transferred to Tasmania Police."
"He knew Jamie Greyson before all of this."
"Or he knew something connected to Jamie. Something that also connects to Killerton Enterprises. Something from fifteen years ago that he never disclosed and never filed and that he pinned to his living room wall where nobody would see it because it was never meant to be part of an official investigation."
Sienna stepped back from the whiteboard. Looked at the whole thing — the web of missing persons and the Berriedale property and the Jeffries Manor connections and the unreported body and the access card and now this. A senior detective who'd connected himself to a missing person and an American construction company through an event fifteen years in the past. A detective who'd found a body and concealed it. A detective who'd been building a private investigation on his living room walls while filing clean, methodical reports at the station.
"What was Karl Jenkins actually doing?" Sienna said.
The question filled the room. Neither of them answered it.
Sienna turned from the whiteboard and opened her document box. Inside, manila folders — tabbed, labelled, arranged in the order she intended to present them. She laid the first three on the table and sat down. Stout sat across from her. The table between them held his files on one side and hers on the other, the two investigations facing each other for the first time.
"Kate Gibbons," Sienna said, opening the first folder. "Evening of the second of August. She called triple zero — reported a break-in at the Berriedale property. Two women she didn't recognise were on the premises. She entered the house, encountered a scene she didn't understand, and armed herself with a knife she found inside." Sienna laid out the crime scene photographs as she spoke — the staircase, the upper living room, the positions documented by her team before the fire erased them. "Responding officers arrived to find her near the top of the stairs holding the weapon. She was in shock. She didn't comply with the instruction to drop it. They fired."
The photographs sat on the table between them. A staircase. A wall. The geometry of a moment that had lasted seconds and ended a life.
"She died in the ambulance," Sienna said. "Kate Gibbons was forty-one. No criminal record. No connection to the property or its occupants that we've established. She appears to have been in the wrong place at the wrong time, responded to what she perceived as a threat, and was killed by the officers she'd called for help."
Stout let that settle. An innocent woman. The kind of detail that changed the temperature of an investigation — not its direction, but its weight.
"Next of kin," Stout said.
"A son. Joel Elijah Gibbons, nineteen years old. Lives with Kate — lived with Kate — in Glenorchy." Sienna's voice caught on the tense correction, the small grammatical shift that marked the difference between a living woman and a dead one. "We've been trying to reach him since the night of the second. Phone goes to voicemail. He hasn't been at the house. Neighbours haven't seen him. His employer — a courier company — says he hasn't shown up for work since the twenty-fifth of July."
"The twenty-fifth."
"Over a week before his mother was killed. He was already missing."
The word settled into the room alongside all the other disappearances that crowded this investigation. Another person gone. Another absence that nobody had reported because nobody had connected it to anything larger.
"And the father?"
"Not in the picture. As far as we can tell, Kate raised Joel alone. No partner listed on any records we've accessed so far. No father's name on the electoral roll, no shared tenancy, nothing."
"Birth records?"
"Requested from the registry on the third. But with the fire and the weekend —" Sienna didn't finish the sentence. She didn't need to. Three days of cascading crises had a way of pushing administrative requests to the bottom of the pile.
"Check now," Stout said. "If your team's been working the Gibbons file over the weekend, someone might have followed it up."
Sienna pulled out her phone. Typed a message — short, direct, the kind of text that expected an answer rather than an acknowledgement. She set the phone on the table between them, screen up.
They returned to the files.
"The two women Kate reported," Stout said. "Sarah Lahey identified them during her interview. Jenny Triffett and Sharon Pafistis. Sarah photographed them leaving the property but didn't report it at the time."
"She photographed them and sat on it."
"She disclosed it during the interview on the third. Presented it as cooperation — I'd call it controlled release. She gave us the names and the photograph on her terms, when withholding them any longer would have looked worse than sharing them."
Sienna made a note. Her pen moved in short, precise strokes — not shorthand, not full sentences, something between the two that served her own system of recording. "Triffett and Pafistis. Those names are familiar."
"They should be. Jenny Triffett is the wife of Nial Triffett — one of the missing persons on Karl's wall. Karl took the initial interview with Jenny, although the case officially sits with Detective Crosswell. Sharon Pafistis is the wife of Adrian Pafistis — another of the missing. Both women are connected to the disappearances through their husbands, and both were inside the Berriedale property the evening Kate Gibbons was shot."
"The wives of two missing men, at the house of a third missing man's partner."
"And nobody has explained why they were there."
"I've assigned officers to bring them both in for formal interviews. As of yesterday, that hadn't happened yet — we've been somewhat occupied." The understatement sat between them. A house fire, a house search, a Saturday that had consumed itself. "They're a priority this week."
Sienna's phone buzzed.
She picked it up. Read the message. Read it again. Her face didn't change — not immediately. The shift came slowly, starting somewhere behind her eyes and moving outward until her whole expression carried the particular stillness of someone absorbing information that rearranged everything they thought they understood.
She turned the phone towards Stout.
The message was from a DS Carrick — one of Sienna's team. Three lines. The first confirmed the birth certificate had been retrieved from the registry's digital records that morning. The second listed Joel Elijah Gibbons' date of birth, mother's name, place of birth. The third line was the one that mattered.
Father: Jamie Nigel Greyson.
Stout read it. Looked at the whiteboard. Found Jamie Greyson's photograph at the top left of Karl's web — the missing man, Luke Smith's partner, the thread that connected to Kain Jeffries and Louise Jeffries and Jeffries Manor and the Berriedale property where Kate Gibbons had been shot dead three nights ago.
Jamie Greyson was Joel Gibbons' father. Kate Gibbons was the mother of Jamie Greyson's child. Kate hadn't been a stranger who wandered into the wrong house. She'd gone to the home of the man who'd fathered her son.
"She knew," Sienna said quietly. "Kate knew whose house it was. She wasn't a bystander. She went there looking for Jamie."
"Or looking for Joel. Her son disappears from work on the twenty-fifth. Jamie Greyson — the father Joel may or may not have known about — lives at the Berriedale address. Kate goes to the house on the evening of the second. Finds two women she doesn't recognise inside. Calls triple zero. Arms herself with a knife because she's terrified."
"Because she was looking for her son and found something else instead."
They sat with it. The weight of it. A mother searching for a missing child, walking into a house connected to a man she'd had a relationship with twenty years ago, finding strangers and chaos and responding the way any parent would — with fear, with a weapon, with the desperate protective instinct that overrode everything else. And then the police she'd called had shot her because she was holding a knife and wouldn't let go.
"Joel's been uncontactable since the twenty-fifth of July," Stout said. "Jamie Greyson has been missing since late July. Father and son, both gone. And the mother who connects them is dead."
Sienna picked up her pen. Drew a new line on her notepad — not on the whiteboard, not yet. A line connecting Kate Gibbons to Jamie Greyson. A line that had been invisible until three minutes ago and that now ran through the centre of everything.
"We need Joel Gibbons," she said. "Alive or otherwise, we need to find him."
The room was quiet for a moment. The fluorescent light hummed. Outside, a car pulled into the station car park — someone else's Sunday interrupted.
Sienna opened the second folder. "The unidentified male. Found in the lower-level living space on the evening of the second — the ground-level room beneath the upper floor. The body was removed to the morgue on the morning of the third, before the fire." She paused to let that register. "Which means we still have him. The autopsy was completed yesterday by Dr Lovell."
She laid out the report summary alongside the crime scene photographs. A body in a room. A face that meant nothing to Stout — male, the features distorted by decomposition and what Sienna's notes described as post-mortem animal predation across the upper torso.
"Male, approximately fifty years old. Cause of death: blunt force trauma. Cervical spine fracture at C2 — his neck struck the doorframe at the bottom of the stairs. Lovell found defensive wounds on the forearms, deep abrasions and contusions consistent with shielding against an attack. Someone fought with this man, and he fell. The fall killed him." Sienna turned a page. "Estimated date of death: approximately the thirty-first of July. He'd been dead for two days before Kate Gibbons walked into that house."
"Identification?"
"Nothing. No wallet, no phone, no identification on the body. No match in missing persons databases. Dental records and DNA are being run but nothing's come back yet. As of now, he's a fifty-year-old man who died in a fight at the bottom of a staircase in a house connected to every thread of your investigation, and nobody knows who he is."
Stout looked at the whiteboard. At the cluster in the lower right corner — the photograph of the access card, Karl's handwritten label: Unidentified male — Berriedale property. The body Karl had found and not reported. The body he'd taken evidence from.
"Karl's wall," Stout said carefully. "The Killerton cluster. He labelled it 'unidentified male — Berriedale property.' He found a body there before your team did. If it's the same person —"
"Then Karl encountered a dead man at the property, removed an access card from the body, concealed the discovery, and began investigating the company on the card instead of reporting a death."
"And days later, your team found the same body in the same house."
"With Kate Gibbons dying upstairs."
The connection tightened between them — Karl's secret and Sienna's crime scene, the same body linking both, the same house holding everything.
"Karl had Luke Smith flagged on his wall," Stout said. "Luke Smith and Jamie Greyson shared that property. Jamie is one of our missing persons — disappeared late July. Luke —" He checked his notes, though he didn't need to. The words were already in his head. "Karl wrote in the margin beside Luke's photograph: Avoided all contact. Never at the address. Background check clean — too clean."
"Too clean," Sienna repeated.
"Karl's phrase. He circled it."
Sienna looked at the whiteboard. At Luke Smith's photograph connected to the Berriedale property connected to Jeffries Manor connected to every missing person Karl had been tracking. "So we have a property shared by Smith and Greyson. Greyson disappears. An unidentified fifty-year-old turns up dead in the lower level with defensive wounds suggesting a fight. Kate Gibbons — mother of Greyson's child — is shot upstairs the same evening the body is discovered. And the next night, someone burns the house to the ground — breaching a police cordon, setting multiple fires, destroying forensic evidence from both levels."
"And removing something from a concealed cavity beneath the wardrobe in the master bedroom before the fire reached it."
They sat with that for a moment. The meeting room was quiet. The fluorescent light hummed above them — the same frequency Stout had noticed in every meeting room in this building, the sound that only became audible when nobody was talking.
"The fire wasn't just destruction," Stout said. "It was selective. Someone knew what was in that house — what your team had found and what they hadn't — and they knew about the cavity, which your team didn't know about. They came prepared. Accelerant, multiple ignition points, thirteen minutes inside a police cordon without being seen. This wasn't panic. This was operational."
"Which means whoever did it had detailed knowledge of my investigation's progress and the property's layout."
"And motivation to destroy evidence from both our cases simultaneously."
The word both sat on the table between the files. Both investigations. Both cases. The same fire, the same night, the same thirteen minutes. Whatever separation had existed between Sienna's homicide and Stout's missing persons had been incinerated along with everything else.
Sienna closed the second folder and opened the third. "The blood evidence. We collected samples from multiple locations through the house on the second and third — the staircase, the upper hallway, the living room, the lower-level room where the body was found. Multiple sources, multiple locations. All of it is at the lab under urgent processing. Results could be days away, but what those samples tell us — who was in that house, how many people bled there, and where — is the only other physical evidence that survived the fire."
"When do you expect results?"
"I pushed for urgent on Friday night. Realistically — Tuesday, maybe Wednesday for the first returns. Full analysis could take longer."
Stout made a note. Tuesday. Wednesday. Days of waiting while the evidence they did have was processed and the evidence they'd lost remained buried or burned.
"Now. Sarah Lahey." He opened his own files. Laid out the interview summary — not the full transcript, but the structure of it. What Sarah had offered. What she'd withheld. The seven-second pauses. The bandaged hand. The badge on the table.
He walked Sienna through it section by section. Sarah's account of the investigation — the missing persons, the connections Karl had been drawing, the visit to the manor on the second of August. Sarah's version of Karl — increasingly withdrawn, obsessive, making decisions she couldn't explain. The evening of the second — Sarah driving to the Berriedale property against Claiborne’s instructions, the photograph of the two women, the discovery that would connect to Kate Gibbons' death twenty-four hours later.
And then the interview's centre of gravity.
"Gladys Cramer," Stout said.
The name entered the room and changed its shape.
"Sarah mentioned her repeatedly. Framed her as peripheral — frustrating, always at the edges, someone Karl was fixated on but who Sarah considered a distraction from the real investigation." Stout paused. "The framing felt deliberate. Sarah was giving us a version of Cramer that she'd decided on before she walked into the room. Enough to seem cooperative. Not enough to explain why Karl was so focused on her."
"Gladys Cramer." Sienna said the name as though she were placing a pin in a map. "She's in my investigation as well."
Stout looked at her.
"The traffic stop on the twenty-ninth of July. Lahey and Jenkins followed a vehicle from the vicinity of the Jeffries property to the Berriedale house. The driver was Gladys Cramer. She had keys to the property — legitimate or otherwise — and she entered the house while they observed. That traffic stop is what first connected my property to your investigation."
"Sarah described it in the interview. She said Karl was convinced Cramer was significant — that she kept appearing wherever the case led. Sarah's position was that Karl was seeing connections that weren't there."
"And your assessment?"
Stout thought about the interview. About Sarah's careful phrasing, her controlled disclosures, the way she'd offered Gladys Cramer like a card played from a hand she'd arranged in advance.
"I think Sarah knows exactly how significant Gladys Cramer is. I think that's why she framed her as insignificant."
Sienna absorbed this without visible reaction. She reached into her document box and produced a single sheet of paper — a printed summary, not a full file, the kind of quick-reference document an investigator assembled when they needed key facts accessible at a glance.
"Gladys May Cramer. Born seventeenth of August 1981. Claremont. Worked at Aurora Energy for thirteen years — compliance and regulatory affairs. Terminated in early July 2018 after a failed workplace alcohol test. No criminal record. Known associate of Jamie Greyson through personal friendship. Greyson's partner is Luke Smith, who co-owned the Berriedale property with Greyson." She set the page on the table between them. "She appears in your investigation through Sarah's interview and Karl's obsession with her movements. She appears in mine through the traffic stop and her connection to the Berriedale property. She held keys to a house where a woman was shot dead and an unidentified body was found."
"And where someone set a fire to destroy whatever evidence remained."
"Yes."
Stout looked at the whiteboard. At the web Karl had built. Gladys Cramer's name wasn't on it — or if it was, it was buried in the handwritten notes that the enlarged photographs couldn't fully resolve. But she was there. She was in the connections between Luke Smith and Jamie Greyson and the Berriedale house. She was in the traffic stop that had first drawn Karl and Sarah to the property. She was in Sarah's interview, offered up and simultaneously minimised. She was everywhere the investigation looked and nowhere it could pin down.
"We need to bring her in," Sienna said.
"Agreed. But carefully. Everything Sarah said about Cramer was curated — which means either Sarah is protecting her or Sarah is afraid of what Cramer might say if we get to her first."
Sienna picked up her cold coffee. Looked at it the way she'd looked at her cold coffee at Berriedale — the brief assessment of a woman deciding whether the caffeine was worth the temperature. She drank it anyway.
"There's something else," Stout said.
Sienna set the coffee down.
"Karl's house. The bedroom." He opened the evidence log from yesterday's search. Laid out Donovan's photographs — the bedside table, the wallet, the keys, the phone, the overnight bag on the queen bed. "Karl's personal effects. Wallet, house keys, mobile phone — all on the bedside table. An overnight bag half-packed on the bed. Dust on the bag's exterior — it had been sitting there untouched for days."
"His wallet and keys should have been with him when he left for work on the morning of the second."
"They should have. And his phone has been unreachable since the afternoon of the second — we assumed it was with him at the manor, dead or destroyed or lost in whatever happened. But it was on his bedside table. Behind a locked front door that our locksmith had to pick to get in."
Sienna was already there. He could see it in her eyes — the same calculation he'd made standing in Karl's bedroom, the same impossible arithmetic.
"Someone returned his effects to his house," she said. "Someone with access to items Karl had on his person when he disappeared. Someone who locked the door behind them."
"And packed a bag. Or placed an already-packed bag. Arranged everything to suggest Karl came home, prepared to leave, and departed voluntarily."
"But the dog."
"The dog hadn't been fed or watered in three days. Karl had a care protocol six pages long. If he'd come home, even briefly, the dog would have been the first thing he attended to."
"So the staging was done by someone who knew Karl's habits well enough to arrange his belongings convincingly but who either didn't know about the dog's needs or didn't care."
"Or couldn't. Jargus is a trained police dog. He wouldn't accept food or handling from a stranger without resistance. Whoever staged that bedroom might have been able to enter the house — the locks are basic, the construction is weatherboard, there are multiple potential access points — but managing a territorial German Shepherd would have been a different matter."
Sienna looked at the photographs. At the wallet aligned with the table's edge. At the phone placed face down. At the overnight bag sitting on the bed with its layer of dust.
"Donovan is running prints from the bedroom surfaces," Stout said. "If whoever staged this wasn't wearing gloves, we'll have them."
"When?"
"He's working through the weekend. Could be today. Could be tomorrow."
Sienna stood. Walked to the whiteboard. Studied Karl's web again, this time with the additional weight of the staged bedroom pressing against everything the web contained.
"Someone disappeared Karl from Jeffries Manor," she said. "Then someone entered his locked house with his personal effects and staged a scene to suggest voluntary departure. Then someone burned down the Berriedale property — destroying evidence from both our investigations and removing something from a concealed cavity. Three separate actions. Three separate scenes. Each one requiring specific knowledge and specific access."
"One person or multiple."
"One person would need to be remarkably capable. Multiple people would need to be remarkably coordinated."
"Either way, we're looking at something organised. Not reactive — planned. Whoever is behind this anticipated the investigation's movements and acted to stay ahead of them."
Sienna turned from the whiteboard. The morning light through the window had shifted as they'd been talking — the angle steeper now, the car park outside brightening as the overcast thinned. They'd been at it for over an hour.
"Gladys Cramer is the common thread," she said. "She connects to both investigations. She had access to the Berriedale property. She's the person Karl was fixated on. She's the person Sarah tried to minimise." Sienna's voice carried the measured weight of a detective building a case brick by brick, testing each one before placing it. "But we don't have enough to bring her in under caution. We need more. The blood results. The print results from Karl's bedroom. The autopsy on the unidentified male. The laptop."
"And the Brody Taylor case file."
Sienna looked at him. "You mentioned that yesterday. Why?"
"Gladys Cramer's background check flagged it. Her name appears in a death investigation from 2014 — a man named Brody Taylor, found dead in a storage unit in Moonah. Gladys discovered the body. The death was ruled accidental." Stout paused. "It was four years ago and it might be nothing. But Gladys Cramer finding a body in 2014 and then turning up at the centre of two connected investigations in 2018 is a coincidence I'd like to understand."
"I'll request the file tomorrow morning."
They looked at the whiteboard. At the table covered in files and photographs and evidence logs. At the shape of something that was larger than either of them had mapped alone and that was still growing, still revealing new edges, still refusing to resolve into a picture they could name.
Stout thought about Woolley in the kitchen. You don't want to end up like Jenkins. The sentence sat beside everything else — beside the staged bedroom and the burned house and Gladys Cramer's keys and Karl's red string and the unidentified body in the lower level and the blood samples waiting at the lab and the prints waiting in Donovan's queue. Another piece in a pattern that grew more complex with every hour and that nobody — not Stout, not Sienna, not Woolley, not Karl before them — had been able to see whole.
"We reconvene when the results come in," Sienna said. "Blood, prints, autopsy. Whichever comes first, we meet and reassess."
"Agreed."
Sienna began repacking her document box. Folders returned to their positions, the summary sheet on Gladys Cramer placed on top where she could reach it without searching. She stood, tucked the box under her arm, reached for her coffee cup.
Stout's phone rang.
The sound stopped Sienna in the doorway. Not because a phone ringing was unusual — because of the way Stout looked at the screen before answering. The brief stillness. The recognition.
"Donovan."
"Stout. I've been at the lab since five this morning." Donovan's voice carried the particular flatness of someone who'd been working for hours and had reached the point where the findings spoke for themselves. "The prints from Jenkins' bedroom. I've run everything through the system. Multiple sets on the surfaces, as expected. Most are consistent with a single male occupant — Jenkins himself. But there's a second set. Clear, distinct, present on the bedside table, the phone screen, the wallet exterior, the overnight bag handles and zip pull."
"Whoever placed those items wasn't wearing gloves."
"No. And the system returned a match on the first pass." A pause — not hesitation, but the precision of a man who reported findings in the order that served accuracy rather than drama. "The prints belong to a Beatrix Evelyn Cramer. Born twelfth of February 1985. She's in the database from a death investigation — a Brody Alastair Taylor, found deceased in a storage unit in Moonah, August 2014. She was printed as the partner of the deceased."
Stout didn't look at Sienna. He didn't need to. He could feel the shift from the doorway — the document box lowering, the weight settling back onto both feet, the departure abandoned.
"Cramer," Stout said.
"Beatrix Evelyn Cramer. That's what the system returned."
"Donovan. The Brody Taylor case file — is there a list of attending officers?"
Papers shuffled. Donovan had pulled the reference. "Investigating officer was Detective Sergeant Holloway, Southern CID. One secondary officer listed — peripheral involvement, attended the initial scene in a support capacity." Another pause. "Detective Constable Karl Jenkins."
Stout closed his eyes. Opened them.
"Thank you, Donovan. Send me everything."
He ended the call. Set the phone on the table.
Sienna was back in the room. The document box was on the table. Her coat was still on. She stood opposite Stout with the whiteboard behind her and Karl's web of red string and pinned connections spread across it like a map of everything they didn't yet understand.
"Beatrix Cramer," Stout said. "Her prints are on Karl's personal effects. The wallet. The phone. The overnight bag. She staged the bedroom."
"Cramer," Sienna said. The word carried its own weight now — not just a surname but a family. A system. "Gladys Cramer's —"
"Sister. Younger sister. Born 1985." Stout stood. Walked to the whiteboard. Found where he'd written Gladys Cramer's name during the briefing and wrote Beatrix Cramer beside it. Drew a line between them. Sisters.
Then he drew another line — from Beatrix to a new point on the board. Brody Taylor — deceased 2014, Moonah. And from that point, a dotted line to Karl Jenkins.
"Karl was listed on the Taylor case file," Stout said. "Peripheral involvement. Attended the initial scene. On paper, it's nothing — a constable doing support work on someone else's investigation." He turned from the whiteboard. "But four years later, that constable's personal effects are in the hands of the deceased's partner. Inside his locked house. Arranged on his bedside table."
"That's not peripheral."
"No."
Sienna looked at the whiteboard. At the two sisters' names sitting side by side, connected to each other, connected to Brody Taylor, connected to Karl, connected through Gladys to everything else — to Jamie Greyson, to Luke Smith, to the Berriedale property, to the traffic stop, to Sarah's interview. The Cramer sisters occupied the space where both investigations overlapped, and the overlap was deeper than either detective had mapped an hour ago.
"We said we needed to find Gladys Cramer," Sienna said. "Now we need to find Beatrix as well."
"Beatrix first. She was inside Karl's house. She handled his belongings. She staged a scene designed to make his disappearance look voluntary. Whatever Gladys knows, Beatrix has done something. That's the difference between a person of interest and a suspect."
Sienna picked up her pen. Not to pack it away — to use it. She pulled her notepad from the document box and began writing.
"Beatrix Evelyn Cramer. Born 1985. Last known association: partner of deceased Brody Taylor, 2014. Current address, current employment, current associations — all unknown." She looked up. "We need everything. Electoral roll, Centrelink records, phone records if we can get authorisation, known associates, vehicle registration. If she's in Hobart, we find her. If she's left, we find out when and where."
"And we need the full Brody Taylor case file. Not a summary — the complete file. Every attending officer's notes, every witness statement, every piece of evidence. Whatever happened in that storage unit in 2014, it connects to what's happening now."
Sienna capped her pen. Looked at the whiteboard one final time — at the web that had grown denser and more tangled with every hour they'd spent in this room. Karl's obsession made visible. And around it now, in Stout's handwriting, the names and connections that Karl hadn't lived long enough to add.
"I'll have my team start on Beatrix first thing tomorrow," she said. "And I'll pull the Taylor file personally."
"Tomorrow."
"Tomorrow." She picked up the document box. Paused at the door — the same pause as before, the one Donovan's call had interrupted. "Stout. The wall."
"I know. Leave it up."
"Add Beatrix. Add everything we've discussed today. And lock this room."
She left. This time her footsteps carried a different rhythm — not unhurried, not hurried. Purposeful. The footsteps of a detective who'd arrived to share information and was leaving with a suspect.
Stout stood alone in the meeting room. The whiteboard held Karl's web and his own additions — Gladys and Beatrix Cramer, Brody Taylor, Kate Gibbons, the lines connecting them all. The table held the files and photographs and evidence logs. The Sunday morning light through the window had shifted again, the overcast breaking apart, pale winter sun reaching across the car park and through the glass.
He picked up his pen. Added two words beneath the web, in his own handwriting.
Who benefits?
He capped the pen. Locked the room. Walked down the empty corridor with Woolley's warning and Donovan's findings and the shape of something that was no longer two investigations but one, and that was moving faster than the people inside it could see.






